Pronoun Agreement and Clarity is a cornerstone of the Standard English Conventions domain on the Digital SAT. While it may seem like a basic grammar topic, the SAT elevates it to a "Medium" difficulty level by embedding these rules within complex, academic passages. In the Writing portion of the Reading and Writing (R&W) modules, you will encounter approximately 1 to 3 questions specifically targeting your ability to link a pronoun to its correct noun (the antecedent).
This skill matters because pronouns are the "connective tissue" of a sentence. If a pronoun is used incorrectly, the logical flow of the passage breaks down. The SAT tests your ability to ensure that every pronoun has a clear, singular, and logically consistent relationship with the noun it replaces. On the Digital SAT, these questions follow a standard format: a short passage (usually 2–4 sentences) with a blank, followed by four answer choices. Your job is to select the pronoun—or sometimes the specific noun—that completes the sentence according to the rules of Standard Written English.
Success in this area requires more than just an "ear" for what sounds right. Because the SAT uses sophisticated vocabulary and distracting prepositional phrases, your "ear" can often be fooled. You must learn to ignore the "noise" of the sentence, identify the true antecedent, and match it in number (singular vs. plural) and person (first, second, or third). Furthermore, you must be able to recognize "ambiguous references," where a pronoun like it or they could technically refer to two different things, creating confusion. This guide will provide you with the technical framework and strategic mindset needed to navigate these questions with 100% accuracy.
Core Concepts
To master Pronoun Agreement and Clarity, you must internalize three primary rules: Number Agreement, Person Agreement, and Reference Clarity.
1. Number Agreement (Singular vs. Plural)
The most common pronoun error on the SAT is a mismatch in number. A singular noun must be replaced by a singular pronoun, and a plural noun must be replaced by a plural pronoun.
- The Rule:
- Singular: The scientist published her findings.
- Plural: The scientists published their findings.
The SAT Trap: Collective Nouns The SAT loves to use "collective nouns"—words that represent a group but are grammatically singular. Common examples include the team, the committee, the agency, the school, the corporation, and the government.
- Incorrect: The tech company released their new software.
- Correct: The tech company released its new software. (The company is one entity).
The SAT Trap: Indefinite Pronouns Words like each, anyone, everyone, everybody, someone, and nobody are always singular.
- Incorrect: Everyone in the room raised their hand.
- Correct: Everyone in the room raised his or her hand. (Note: While "their" is becoming more common in spoken English as a singular pronoun, the SAT typically tests traditional singular agreement unless the context specifically identifies a non-binary individual).
2. Person Agreement (Consistency)
Person refers to the perspective of the pronoun:
- 1st Person: I, we, me, us
- 2nd Person: You
- 3rd Person: He, she, it, they, one
The SAT requires you to stay consistent within a sentence or passage. If a passage starts with the impersonal one, it must continue with one.
- Incorrect: If one wants to succeed in music, you must practice daily.
- Correct: If one wants to succeed in music, one must practice daily.
3. Pronoun Clarity and Ambiguity
A pronoun must refer to one, and only one, clear noun. If a sentence contains two nouns that a pronoun could logically replace, the pronoun is "ambiguous," and the SAT will require you to replace it with the specific noun to maintain clarity.
- Ambiguous: The teacher told the student that she had won the award. (Who won? The teacher or the student?)
- Clear: The teacher told the student that the student had won the award.
4. Relative Pronouns
Relative pronouns introduce descriptive clauses. You must choose the one that matches the type of noun being described:
- Who/Whom: Used for people only.
- Which: Used for things/objects only.
- That: Used for people or things.
- Where: Used for physical locations only.
- When: Used for periods of time only.
Example:
- Incorrect: The era where jazz was popular...
- Correct: The era when jazz was popular... (An era is a time, not a place).
SAT Strategy Tips
1. The "Vertical Scan"
Before reading the passage, glance at the answer choices. If you see a mix of singular and plural pronouns (e.g., it, they, its, their), you immediately know the question is testing Number Agreement. This allows you to read the passage with one goal: find the antecedent.
2. Ignore the "Middle Men"
The SAT often places long prepositional phrases or appositives between the noun and the pronoun to distract you. Cross them out to see the relationship clearly.
- The discovery [of the ancient ruins located deep within the dense jungles of the Yucatan Peninsula] revealed its secrets.
- By ignoring the bracketed text, you see that "discovery" (singular) matches "its" (singular).
3. The "Ambiguity Check"
If the answer choices include both a pronoun (like them) and a specific noun (like the documents), be on high alert. Usually, the specific noun is the correct answer because it eliminates any possible ambiguity. The SAT prefers clarity over brevity.
4. Time Management
You should aim to solve these in under 45 seconds. Because these are rule-based rather than interpretation-based, they are "bankable" time-savers. Identify the noun, check the number, and move on.
5. Watch for "Its" vs. "It's"
- Its: Possessive (belonging to it).
- It's: Contraction (it is).
- Its': Not a word. Never pick it.
Worked Example: Easy (Number Agreement
The bioluminescent glow of the Pyrocystis fusiformis algae is triggered by mechanical stress. When the surrounding water is disturbed by a predator, the algae flash brightly, potentially startling ______ and making the predator visible to its own hunters.
A) them B) it C) those D) they
Reasoning:
- Identify the antecedent: Who is being startled? The "predator."
- Determine number: "Predator" is singular.
- Evaluate choices:
- (A) "them" is plural.
- (B) "it" is singular and functions as an object.
- (C) "those" is plural.
- (D) "they" is plural and a subject pronoun.
- Conclusion: (B) is correct because it matches the singular "predator."
Worked Example: Medium (Collective Nouns
Founded in 1958, the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) has overseen countless missions to explore the solar system. While many people view the agency as a purely scientific body, ______ also plays a significant role in developing new aviation technologies.
A) they B) these C) it D) some
Reasoning:
- Identify the antecedent: The subject is "the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA)" or "the agency."
- Determine number: Even though NASA consists of thousands of people, the "agency" is a single organization (a collective noun). Therefore, it is singular.
- Evaluate choices:
- (A) "they" is plural.
- (B) "these" is plural.
- (C) "it" is singular.
- (D) "some" is plural/indefinite.
- Conclusion: (C) is correct. The agency is an "it," not a "they."
Worked Example: Hard (Clarity and Ambiguity
In 1922, archaeologist Howard Carter and his benefactor Lord Carnarvon finally entered the tomb of Tutankhamun. Although Carter was an expert in Egyptian history, ______ had provided the financial backing necessary for the multi-year excavation.
A) he B) they C) Carnarvon D) that
Reasoning:
- Identify the antecedent: The sentence mentions two men: Howard Carter and Lord Carnarvon.
- Check for ambiguity: If we use the pronoun "he" (Choice A), the reader won't know for certain if it refers to Carter or Carnarvon. While the context of the sentence suggests the benefactor, "he" is still grammatically ambiguous because there are two males in the preceding sentence.
- Evaluate choices:
- (A) "he" is ambiguous.
- (B) "they" is plural and logically incorrect (only one person provided the backing).
- (C) "Carnarvon" is a specific noun that removes all doubt.
- (D) "that" is an incorrect relative pronoun for a person.
- Conclusion: (C) is correct. When a pronoun could refer to two different people or things, the SAT requires the specific noun to ensure clarity.
Practice Problems
Problem 1
The internal combustion engine relies on a series of timed explosions to move pistons within a cylinder. As the piston moves downward, ______ creates a vacuum that draws a mixture of fuel and air into the chamber.
A) they B) it C) these D) those
Problem 2
Biologists studying the migration patterns of Arctic terns have discovered that the birds travel over 44,000 miles annually. By tracking the terns, ______ can better understand how climate change affects global migratory routes.
A) one B) he C) researchers D) it
Problem 3
Each of the participants in the study was required to submit a detailed log of ______ daily caloric intake and exercise habits for a period of six months.
A) their B) its C) his or her D) there
Want to check your answers and get step-by-step solutions?
Common Mistakes
1. The "Singular They" Trap
In casual conversation, we almost always use "they" to refer to a single person of unknown gender (e.g., "Someone left their umbrella"). However, on the SAT, if the antecedent is a singular indefinite pronoun like someone, everyone, or each, the test traditionally looks for the singular his or her.
- How to avoid: If you see "they" in the answer choices, double-check if the noun is truly plural. If the noun is "The student" or "Each person," "they" is likely a trap.
2. Confusing "Its" and "Their" for Companies
Students often think of companies or groups as "they" because they are made of people.
- The Mistake: "Apple released their new iPhone."
- The Fix: A company is a single legal entity. Always use "its."
3. Misidentifying the Antecedent
The SAT will place a plural noun right before the blank to trick you into picking a plural pronoun, even if the real subject is singular.
- Example: "The collection of rare stamps was famous for their variety."
- The Fix: "Collection" is the subject; "stamps" is just part of a prepositional phrase. The correct pronoun is "its."
4. Picking "Its'"
This is a "nonsense" choice. The SAT includes "its'" (with an apostrophe after the s) to catch students who are guessing.
- The Fix: "Its'" does not exist in the English language. Never select it.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if a question is testing Pronoun Agreement or just Vocabulary?
A: Look at the answer choices. If the choices are different versions of the same idea (e.g., it, they, its, their, one), it is a grammar question about pronouns. If the choices are four completely different nouns, it is a vocabulary or "Clarity" question.
What if "his or her" isn't an option, but the noun is singular?
A: On the Digital SAT, the test makers are increasingly avoiding the clunky "his or her" by either making the antecedent plural (so "they" is correct) or using a specific noun. If you are forced to choose between a plural pronoun and a singular one for a singular noun, always stick to the singular rule.
Is "one" always the correct answer if it appears?
A: No. "One" is only correct if the sentence has already established "one" as the perspective. For example: "If one is tired, one should sleep." If the sentence says "If you are tired," then "one" would be wrong.
Key Takeaways
Match the Number: Singular nouns get singular pronouns (it, its); plural nouns get plural pronouns (they, them, their).
Collective Nouns are Singular: Treat the team, the group, the committee, and the company as singular "its."
Clarity is King: If a pronoun like "it" or "he" could refer to two different things, choose the specific noun instead.
Watch the "Middle Men": Cross out prepositional phrases (starting with of, in, by, with) to find the real noun.
Relative Pronouns: Use who for people, which for things, where for places, and when for time.
Its vs. It's: Its shows possession; it's means "it is." Its' is never correct.